The theme for Season 10 of Ryan Murphy’s horror anthology American Horror Story is all but confirmed… and it’s to do with mermaids and sirens!

We are FULLY gagged on this theme. (However, we did say the same about Apocalypse and look how that turned out…)

Fans are speculating since Murphy posted an image of a tattooed tongue and dentist holding the tool responsible.

Upon first glance, with the red lips and sharp teeth some fans thought the theme was vampires… however, considering all the teeth are sharp, this is more indicative of fish.

Adding to that, the clues that Murphy has dropped in the past, including a set of similar-looking teeth.

Far from Murphy’s usual visual feast, a clever fan pointed out that the slightly-pixelated image is what pops up when you google “Siren Teeth”.

Before that Murphy posted a “clue” of a beach and knocked down fence and and hands grappling onto an edge over the water, along with the caption “things are beginning to wash up on shore”.

View this post on Instagram

American Horror Story. Clue.

A post shared by Ryan Murphy (@mrrpmurphy) on

View this post on Instagram

Things are beginning to wash up on shore…

A post shared by Ryan Murphy (@mrrpmurphy) on

This season’s cast will include Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Cathy Bates, Macaulay Culkin. Leslie Grossman, Billie Lourd, Adina Porter, Lily Rabe, Finn Wittrock and Pose legend Angelica Ross.