It wouldn’t be American Horror Story if Evan Peters wasn’t getting down and dirty. After topping Colton Haynes in the last season of the show, Peters proves he can play both roles in the bedroom.

As the plot for Apocalypse becomes more ominous, we saw the first major tie-in with season 1’s Murder House as Murphy brought back the iconic rubber man. We could probably do with a rewatch and a refresh (Murder House aired seven years ago), but one of the unforgettable characters was the anonymous, silent and strangely sexual rubber man. He’ll poke you up the bum, and then stab you in the heart.

In the most recent scene Peters was sure he was liaising with Michael Langdon – who entered the bunker in episode one and then questioned Peters about his sexuality. But that would obviously be far too straightforward for Ryan Murphy…

American Horror Story continues on FX on Wednesdays.